Skip to content
Sports Index
News
Sports Index Desk September 11, 2026 2 min read 5 sources cited

Michigan Hosts Oklahoma as Home Underdog With Underwood's Job in Question

Kyle Whittingham says no spot on Michigan's depth chart is permanent as the Wolverines open as underdogs against the Sooners in Ann Arbor.

via Sporting News CFB

Michigan will host Oklahoma at Michigan Stadium on Saturday at noon ET on FOX, and the Wolverines enter their first marquee test of the 2026 season as a home underdog with questions swirling around sophomore quarterback Bryce Underwood.

Both teams are 1-0, but arrived there by very different routes. Oklahoma shut out UTEP 51-0 in its opener, while Michigan needed a Hail Mary touchdown pass from Underwood to edge Western Michigan 13-12 at home as a 28.5-point favorite, a finish complicated by a clock controversy. Michigan was listed as a 5.5-point underdog in one report and 4.5 in another. Michigan was ranked No. 24 in the USA TODAY Sports Coaches Poll roundup of Week 2 matchups, with Oklahoma ranked in the top 10 or just outside it depending on the poll.

Underwood completed 12 passes for 170 yards against the Broncos, with an interception and a fourth-quarter fumble. Asked Monday whether Underwood's place atop the depth chart was permanent, first-year head coach Kyle Whittingham did not offer a guarantee.

He's our quarterback right now. It's not something that's infinite. We need to see improvement with a bunch of stuff... it's not just Bryce's job that's set in concrete. Nobody's job is.

— Michigan coach Kyle Whittingham

A day later, Underwood said he was unaware of the remarks. "There was comments about that?" he told a reporter, before responding, "That's cool," when the comments were described to him. Behind Underwood on the depth chart is true freshman Tommy Carr, a four-star prospect from Saline, Mich., whose grandfather Lloyd Carr coached Michigan from 1995 to 2007 and whose brother CJ starts at Notre Dame. Colorado State transfer Brayden Fowler-Nicolosi, who made 28 starts for the Rams, is next, followed by sophomore Chase Herbstreit and freshman Brady Smiegel.

Consensus leans Sooners

Six of seven USA TODAY Sports panelists picked Oklahoma. Three of four Fighting Irish Wire staffers also took the Sooners, with one citing Michigan's offensive struggles and another noting that Oklahoma quarterback John Mateer and Brent Venables' defense give the visitors an edge on both sides of the ball. Baker Mayfield, the 2017 Heisman Trophy winner at Oklahoma, told ESPN he expects a lopsided result and singled out Buccaneers teammates with Michigan ties.

I don't expect it to be a close one. We've got Larry Foote, one of our coaches on the defensive side of the ball. Our left guard, Ben Bredeson, also a Michigan guy, so there's a lot of animosity in the building, which is good.

— Baker Mayfield, via ESPN

Interest in the game has cooled locally. According to TicketData.com, the get-in price at Michigan Stadium fell from $120 to $59 over three days, a 51% drop. By comparison, the cheapest ticket for No. 1 Ohio State at Texas in Austin sat at $451 after peaking at $512.

Whittingham has asked for improvement across the roster, including more decisive running from his backs, better protection up front and separation from receivers other than JJ Buchanan. Michigan did not force a turnover against Western Michigan, a point the coach emphasized during his Monday press conference.

Discuss this story

Repost story

No one has opened a room for this story yet.

Go to Discuss