Texas' 24-23 Comeback at Ohio State Reshapes Top of AP Poll
Arch Manning and Hollywood Smothers erased a 20-point deficit in Austin, lifting the Longhorns to No. 1 and leaving Ohio State at No. 6 with questions about its offensive balance.
Three days after Texas erased a 20-point deficit to beat Ohio State 24-23 in Austin, the fallout from the Week 2 result continued to shape the national picture. The Longhorns, who trailed 20-3 at halftime and 23-3 entering the fourth quarter, moved to the top of the AP Top 25, while the Buckeyes dropped from No. 1 to No. 6.
Arch Manning and running back Hollywood Smothers drove the 21-point fourth quarter. Manning's touchdown pass to Ryan Wingo capped a 91-yard drive to cut the margin to 23-10, and Smothers followed with a 1-yard score to make it 23-17. After Ohio State missed a field goal, Texas went 73 yards in 12 plays and Smothers punched in the go-ahead touchdown. The Texas defense held the Buckeyes to 52 yards in the final quarter.
Manning finished 23-of-37 for 195 yards with a touchdown and a first-half interception. Smothers rushed for 74 yards and Raleek Brown added 54. ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit credited both Manning and coach Steve Sarkisian in an appearance on Nonstop with Joey Galloway.
Texas saved their season, not just with one game. It's just what that did for morale, what that did for belief. All kudos to Sark and to Texas. Team effort – defense, offense, the whole thing.
— Kirk Herbstreit, ESPN analyst
Buckeyes face balance questions
In Columbus, the conversation turned to Ohio State's distribution of targets. Wide receiver Jeremiah Smith was targeted 15 times and finished with eight catches for 164 yards and a touchdown, while the Buckeyes' other receivers drew five targets for two receptions and 24 yards. CBS Sports analyst Tom Fornelli said he wondered "if maybe Ohio State is being too reliant on Jeremiah Smith," while 247Sports labeled Smith the Week 2 Heisman frontrunner and noted a single loss does not remove Ohio State from the playoff race. Smith is in his third season with the program.
Bowl projections following Week 2 kept Ohio State in the College Football Playoff field, with the Buckeyes still viewed as Big Ten favorites ahead of Indiana. Oregon, upset by Oklahoma State, and Oklahoma, which lost to Michigan, were moved out of the projected bracket, with SMU and Penn State rising into position. Michigan coach Kyle Whittingham, asked by Barstool Sports founder Dave Portnoy about the fourth quarter in Austin, said he thought "the game was in the bag after three quarters" and called the comeback amazing.
Manning also drew criticism on Monday after laughing about an AI-generated video depicting Sarkisian slapping ESPN sideline reporter Holly Rowe, which he described as "hilarious" when asked about social media edits of the game. Sarkisian had cut short his postgame interview with Rowe on Saturday, saying, "That's called Texas fight. Hook 'em," before walking off.
Both teams close non-conference play this weekend. Texas hosts UTSA before opening Southeastern Conference play at Tennessee in Week 4. Ohio State faces Kent State as a 52.5-point favorite, with the SP+ model projecting a 53-0 Buckeyes win.
Sources
6 cited- 01 With a little bit of time, how are you feeling about the loss to Texas?
- 02 Kirk Herbstreit: Texas 'saved their season' with comeback win over Ohio State
- 03 ‘Ohio State Is Too Reliant on Jeremiah Smith’ — Buckeyes Called Out for ‘Chasing’ WR’s Heisman Trophy After Texas Loss
- 04 Michigan football news: Kyle Whittingham loved Ohio State's loss to Texas
- 05 Arch Manning facing backlash for laughing at AI video of Steve Sarkisian, Holly Rowe
- 06 Penn State, SMU lead winners of college football bowl projections after Week 2
Discuss this story
Repost storyNo one has opened a room for this story yet.
Go to Discuss