Skip to content
Sports Index
News
Sports Index Desk October 20, 2026 3 min read 4 sources cited

BYU climbs to No. 2 after upsetting Notre Dame; Sitake tells Cougars to keep the rat poison away

The Cougars vaulted from No. 8 to a program-best No. 2 in the AP Top 25 after edging Notre Dame, but Kalani Sitake wants his players to stay humble and hungry.

via SB Nation: Underdog Dynasty

BYU climbed to No. 2 in the country on Sunday after rallying past Notre Dame 28-24 in Provo, spoiling the Fighting Irish's undefeated season and securing the Big 12's second AP Top 10 win of the year. Tight end Walker Lyons caught the game-winning touchdown pass from AP National Player of the Week Bear Bachmeier with 1:47 remaining, capping a comeback after special teams miscues — a muffed punt and a failed fake punt — helped Notre Dame claw back from a 21-10 deficit to take a 24-21 lead. The Cougars improved to 6-0 and received 20 first-place votes in the AP poll.

The ranking is BYU's highest since the 1984 national championship season and the first time in program history the Cougars have been ranked No. 2. Notre Dame, which suffered its first loss of the season, nonetheless remained in the top 10 of the US LBM Coaches Poll, sitting at No. 5 in Fox Sports analyst Joel Klatt's updated top 10 released Monday. Klatt said the Irish are still in the College Football Playoff conversation and argued they should have had another play in the final seconds because the call should have gone to replay.

Sitake: 'Keep the rat poison away from the boys'

At his weekly press briefing Monday, BYU's 11th-year coach brushed off the vault from No. 8 to within a whisker of No. 1, saying rankings will do nothing to help the Cougars beat well-rested UCF (3-3, 1-2) on Saturday in Orlando, Florida. Kickoff at the Acrisure Bounce House is set for 1:30 p.m. MDT on Fox.

Nope, never cared about it before. So why would I start now? You guys like it, so I'll let you guys handle that stuff. Just keep the rat poison away from the boys. We're fine. This is no disrespect to the voters and everyone that puts it together. Appreciate it. But we're talking about (staying) humble and hungry, so talking about rankings isn't going to get us there.

— Kalani Sitake

The players echoed their coach's message. Freshman receiver Legend Glasker called it 'crazy' that BYU is the No. 2 team in the country but said the ranking is not the end goal for a team that is No. 3 in the coaches poll. Lyons said the Cougars are grateful but see 'a lot of football left,' noting the offense is still a work in progress despite putting up 28 points on Notre Dame — more than any Irish opponent since a 41-40 loss to Texas A&M in 2025. Junior safety Faletua Satuala, who helped hold the Irish to their lowest point total since Week 2 last season, said the Cougars must focus on going 1-0 every week, since one loss can send a team 'dropping pretty quickly.'

The win lifted the Big 12's overall playoff profile. The conference now showcases three of the six undefeated teams in the FBS — BYU, No. 8 Texas Tech and No. 10 Utah — and with No. 14 Houston, Arizona at No. 25 and Oklahoma State just outside the rankings, four Big 12 teams sit inside the AP Top 15. There are zero undefeated SEC teams and only one in the Big Ten (UCLA), leaving a top-heavy Big 12 positioned for multiple selections in the 12-team CFP field after receiving only one bid last season. College GameDay, which spent the weekend in Provo, heads to Salt Lake City for Saturday's Utah-Houston showdown.

Discuss this story

Repost story

No one has opened a room for this story yet.

Go to Discuss